Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) as electrocatalysts for the alkaline oxygen evolution reaction (OER) show promising catalytic activity by offering great variability and high surface areas, enabling performance optimization and mechanistic studies. However, their stability during reaction and the structure-performance relationship defining the origin of the high OER activity, are still vigorously debated. Herein, we leverage operando X-ray absorption spectroscopy and operando X-ray diffraction to unveil the structural and electronic transformations of Ni-MOF-74 during OER. We identify the irreversible destruction of the MOF-74 crystal into a highly OER active, amorphous NiOOH-metal organic compound. Based on these findings, we propose an amorphous Ni metal organic compound (Ni-MOC*) for achieving high current densities both in a three-electrode cell (14 A gNi-1 at 1.5 VRHE) and in an anion exchange membrane water electrolyzer (AEM-WE) with a stable AEM-WE performance exceeding 100 h at 500 mA cm-2.