The oceans store vast amounts dissolved organic carbon (DOC) that can resist microbial degradation for thousands of years. The mechanisms that underlie the long-term stability of DOC in the ocean are still debated. Microorganisms in this environment exhibit low metabolic activity and are energetically starved. We tested whether the microbial degradation of DOC could be stimulated through the addition of labile compounds. Surprisingly, alleviating energetic constraints did not stimulate the consumption of deep ocean DOC. Additionally, our results suggest that competition among taxa is an important constraint on dissolved organic carbon consumption, with implications for ecosystem processing. Our study indicates that an increase in fresh organic carbon to the deep ocean may enhance carbon sequestration since marine microbes are known to produce recalcitrant compounds. This finding is of consequence for ongoing geoengineering efforts that aim to remove atmospheric carbon by increasing carbon export to the deep sea.